Subject: Re: shared-memory based stats collector
From: Tomas Vondra <tomas.vondra@2ndquadrant.com>
To: Kyotaro HORIGUCHI <horiguchi.kyotaro@lab.ntt.co.jp>
Cc: alvherre@2ndquadrant.com, andres@anarazel.de, ah@cybertec.at,
 magnus@hagander.net, robertmhaas@gmail.com, tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us,
 pgsql-hackers@postgresql.org
References: <20181108153941.txjb6rg3y7q26ldm@alvherre.pgsql>
 <20181109.173315.29453727.horiguchi.kyotaro@lab.ntt.co.jp>
 <803f2d96-3b4b-f357-9a2e-45443212f13d@2ndquadrant.com>
 <20181112.201042.147595779.horiguchi.kyotaro@lab.ntt.co.jp>
 <8e041a34a70ae5d44cb10a7e516308e2f6d1b651.camel@2ndquadrant.com>
Message-ID: <6c079a69-feba-e47c-7b85-8a9ff31adef3@2ndquadrant.com>
Date: Mon, 26 Nov 2018 02:52:30 +0100
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101
 Thunderbird/60.3.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <8e041a34a70ae5d44cb10a7e516308e2f6d1b651.camel@2ndquadrant.com>
Content-Type: multipart/mixed;
 boundary="------------E1B83F73CCBC07C9A3D11A9C"
Content-Language: en-US
Precedence: bulk

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------E1B83F73CCBC07C9A3D11A9C
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

Hi,

Unfortunately, the patch does not apply anymore - it seems it got broken
by the changes to signal handling and/or removal of magic OIDs :-(

I've done a review and testing when applied on top of 10074651e335.

Firstly, the testing - I was wondering if the patch has some performance
impact, so I've done some testing with a read-only workload on large
number of tables (1k, 10k and 100k) while concurrently selecting data
from pg_stat_* catalogs at the same time.

In one case both workloads were running against the same database, in
another there were two separate databases (and the selects from stat
catalogs were running against an "empty" database with no use tables).

In both cases there were 8 clients doing selects from the user tables,
and 4 clients accessing the pg_stat_* catalogs.

For the "single database" case the results looks like this (this is just
patched / master throughput):

    # of tables     xact     stats
    ------------------------------
    1000          97.71%    98.76%
    10000        100.38%    97.97%
    100000       100.10%    98.50%

xact is throughput of the user workload (select from the large number of
tables) and stats is throughput for selects from system catalogs.

So pretty much no difference - 2% is within noise on this machine.

On two separate databases the results are a bit more interesting:

    # of tables     xact      stats
    -------------------------------
    1000         100.49%     80.38%
    10000        103.18%     80.28%
    100000       100.85%     81.95%

For the main workload there's pretty much no difference, but for selects
from the stats catalogs there's ~20% drop in throughput. In absolute
numbers this means drop from ~670tps to ~550tps. I haven't investigated
this, but I suppose this is due to dshash seqscan being more expensive
than reading the data from file.

I don't think any of this is an issue in practice, though. The important
thing is that there's no measurable impact on the regular workload.

Now, a couple of comments regarding individual parts of the patch.


0001-0003
---------

I do think 0001 - 0003 are ready, with some minor cosmetic issues:

1) I'd rephrase the last part of dshash_seq_init comment more like this:

* If consistent is set for dshash_seq_init, the all hash table
* partitions are locked in the requested mode (as determined by the
* exclusive flag), and the locks are held until the end of the scan.
* Otherwise the partition locks are acquired and released as needed
* during the scan (up to two partitions may be locked at the same time).

Maybe it should briefly explain what the consistency guarantees are (and
aren't), but considering we're not materially changing the existing
behavior probably  is not really necessary.

2) I think the dshash_find_extended() signature should be more like
dshash_find(), i.e. just appending parameters instead of moving them
around unnecessarily. Perhaps we should add

    Assert(nowait || !lock_acquired);

Using nowait=false with lock_acquired!=NULL does not seem sensible.

3) I suppose this comment in postmaster.c is just copy-paste:

-#define BACKEND_TYPE_ARCHIVER	0x0010	/* bgworker process */
+#define BACKEND_TYPE_ARCHIVER	0x0010	/* archiver process */

I wonder why wasn't archiver a regular auxiliary process already? It
seems like a fairly natural thing, so why not?


0004 (+0005 and 0007)
---------------------

This seems fine, but I have my doubts about two changes - removing of
stats_temp_directory and the IDLE_STATS_UPDATE_TIMEOUT thingy.

There's a couple of issues with the stats_temp_directory. Firstly, I
don't understand why it's spread over multiple parts of the patch. The
GUC is removed in 0004, the underlying variable is removed in 0005 and
then the docs are updated in 0007. If we really want to do this, it
should happen in a single patch.

But the main question is - do we really want to do that? I understand
this directory was meant for the stats data we're moving to shared
memory, so removing it seems natural. But clearly it's used by
pg_stat_statements - 0005 fixes that, of course, but I wonder if there
are other extensions using it to store files?

It's not just about how intensive I/O to those files is, but this also
means the files will now be included in backups / pg_rewind, and maybe
that's not really desirable?

Maybe it's fine but I'm not quite convinced about it ...

I'm not sure I understand what IDLE_STATS_UPDATE_TIMEOUT does. You've
described it as

   This adds a new timeout IDLE_STATS_UPDATE_TIMEOUT. This works
   similarly to IDLE_IN_TRANSACTIION_SESSION_TIMEOUT. It fires in
   at most PGSTAT_STAT_MIN_INTERVAL(500)ms to clean up pending
   statistics update.

but I'm not sure what pending updates do you mean? Aren't we updating
the stats at the end of each transaction? At least that's what we've
been doing before, so maybe this patch changes that?


regards

-- 
Tomas Vondra                  http://www.2ndQuadrant.com
PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Remote DBA, Training & Services

--------------E1B83F73CCBC07C9A3D11A9C
Content-Type: image/png;
 name="chart.png"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename="chart.png"
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--------------E1B83F73CCBC07C9A3D11A9C--