X-Original-To: pgsql-performance-postgresql.org@localhost.postgresql.org Received: from localhost (mx1.hub.org [200.46.208.251]) by postgresql.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 21F2B11F6089 for ; Tue, 25 Apr 2006 13:56:31 -0300 (ADT) Received: from postgresql.org ([200.46.204.71]) by localhost (mx1.hub.org [200.46.208.251]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 47638-06 for ; Tue, 25 Apr 2006 13:56:15 -0300 (ADT) X-Greylist: delayed 00:18:02.033648 by SQLgrey- Received: from svr4.postgresql.org (svr4.postgresql.org [66.98.251.159]) by postgresql.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id BDFBD11F60E5 for ; Tue, 25 Apr 2006 13:56:08 -0300 (ADT) Received: from techforce.com.br (techforce.com.br [216.218.247.150]) by svr4.postgresql.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id C27385B2EB6 for ; Tue, 25 Apr 2006 16:38:05 +0000 (GMT) Received: from techforce.com.br (techforce.com.br [127.0.0.1]) by techforce.com.br (8.12.11/8.12.11) with ESMTP id k3PGcGUq023353 for ; Tue, 25 Apr 2006 09:38:17 -0700 From: "andremachado" To: pgsql-performance@postgresql.org Subject: Firebird 1.5.3 X Postgresql 8.1.3 (linux and windows) Date: Tue, 25 Apr 2006 14:38:16 -0200 Message-Id: <20060425160609.M20649@techforce.com.br> X-Mailer: Open WebMail 2.51 20050228 X-OriginatingIP: 161.148.39.27 (andremachado@techforce.com.br) MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="----=OPENWEBMAIL_ATT_0.810408543420152" X-Virus-Scanned: Maia Mailguard 1.0.1 X-Archive-Number: 200604/555 X-Sequence-Number: 18639 This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=OPENWEBMAIL_ATT_0.810408543420152 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1 Hello, The performance comparison saga of the last month continues (see list archive). After some time experimenting on windows, the conclusion is clear: windows is likely crap for databases other than MS-SQL. I guess that MS-SQL uses lot of undocumented api calls, may run in kernel mode, ring 0 and a lot of dirty tricks to get some reasonable performance. Then, I asked my coleague to send a new FB dump and a Pg dump to try at my desktop machine. This time, the database is somewhat bigger. Around 20 million records. The timings are attached. Tried to follow the same query sequence on both files. Both databases are much more faster on linux than on windows, and the desktop machine is not dedicated and tuned. (no scsi, no raid, many services enabled, ext3 fs, etc). At many of the queries, postgresql is faster, sometimes way MUCH faster. But Firebird have very good defaults out of the box and a few of the queries are really a pain in Postgresql. Please, see the abismal timing differences at the last 2 queries, for example. They used 100% cpu, almost no disk activity, no twait cpu, for loooong time to complete. Maybe these queries bring into the light some instructions weaknesses, or bad tuning. Do you have some suggestions? Regards. Andre Felipe Machado http://www.techforce.com.br linux blog ------=OPENWEBMAIL_ATT_0.810408543420152 Content-Type: application/x-gzip; name="queries_timing_firebird.txt.tar.gz" Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="queries_timing_firebird.txt.tar.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 H4sICLxMTkQAAzlTWWp0YS50YXIA7VrbbttGEPUzv6CP+1AEVmBTe+NNqYoystQysCVHkp2HoiBo a+2okCiZpFL7rf/Qn+vndEjxfrGj1LkU1cIAyZ3d2dXsmTMzC99thDcXvh3Ml3P31r6Ze+Jq7s3k 4D44eK6GCcYq5wd/wvt3L/76G1OmaYwf4KgRTdPwAcGcMvgjGoHxKsf4AOFn28EjbeMHjofQgXMj FvO1aBznb1y/WfqfbZO3pz8iXwQIzBD4aOW+kqS4byGuA3S92rjBoXViW9P+WQvdeKslOun3Ts2x 2TNH0StCc9cVHvp9NXdRzzwxJ9PxKHwBbegQnjJMz+Z0w9diVwuFLadlOJqa9sCa9MxTNBxEeoaD cE6ivhurTb5b+dnhVu1QBbLiydZ29nDQTV5a6I/3whMo2Yw5fnthXY66BH4/2rbe6GI4lbq5FosI UQCuTJJ6G88TboCWYrnyHlAXaZrCFFU6EYvAyXqxdObcZ5+6glWVS/2Fs/bFDIHniS4iTKYcjH4t 9dabcI6McfT5enNzIzwfuijmujQWziz8YLpicOmdNw+EHy0xEMH1++hdhU1oOtueo4S2xzm6mJ5f TFH7/Wop2jHW24FYrturTbDeBDI84KffzBeig+6AFB5sJ9g4C9m/W3SkGAwv/wfnL0m/xub5CcUv v32PZk4g0IsXqL1aB+2EJNtXc7c9BwOh47kLNqyz7mJ+v2LtkkHR8dbojx8HOr6Y9MfIf/BnVw46 Pjcnk3ej8Qm6Dxsqb2U2c2/km9lVuMtwt9JE3CLzykMAK0I6lHe4gV6PJ5eAI6yWpAx3MMtJa0zw Ze0yEx/a7maxeFYbMDDDIzbgHaY9ZYMmB9msI0vkcRux6qVpT6HvNKTP4eQE4NhFh7E3+ZvlYQpV ORkZc2yG4S1Os4ERfEFNbq0E0vFYcT/3gcuTdUquUuPDR0W3TTwj5xfgXuiQ4BZy3BmquDTsZjs6 15UfmWqv7DqVoK3qz2ebH5CRa6++LTiL0/6b1/zyl10RzVmHa42I5kqH8ycRLSXsHpLky7KFQwb9 GGIGarUybn0kIKQRIaXyIrMXJhdQGq1Wxlm3AsZWHX677FU1WhuMcM6fiNaGwYmql6I1lomyQ7DG 9YGaYEPXSBynpTjv+qaYZDsi9P14peGAxtOqLLJzGlA+twachYvGSKOP5wCNxNVCrZrzJzrWGamk a8SA/KyEAqJxVae0krYZRNbxDkhQoBZiGRqIoqqU5CDBKfQYWIlBUZOdV5PzGbD93I0OJz4b4FIf hG7g3IrlUWgQ88we9wf9cX/Ys8xI6izXq7pD/FynuHsa1z87H/cnZviMpsIzHBt3xyvHX4WJ8dHb 5+NRrz+ZmCejsCvSAc88KxSg0kK33mqzRlcPVYutvBlor5HE5UJvNJyaP/fPUFI7mGfno0LtgGoK iW2jyRNjhnleQvISJZMoCs8kHBuZRMV5CcGphFFDyUtIKiFUL0hoJtENNZMAdFMJJZjmJdkcCqK8 hGXaNM7zkvSXEqqywjrJL9UYIbSwjppIwHWJkpdoObsxPS/Ra+o0naoa/NCS41PoKzt+PLLk9bJq 7FKrAW801GqMck3Ted7dawLAM/H/LgFgO7QxW8uFhKfTy39NKY8lpEB2n5I5xjo/LXes1v3gd7r+ VCZBdELLAUTjMoD/47GkMr2p7qc6U6Hu19OEIqxVEOShNZV82cZHCMgyOojweTEd2aOBBfR2ehRG ld7I7g3P39i98wHMmUytoTk1xxbMiqwNIzI7Q2z54NjBKnAWR8nt0Zb0tzdIIL8LZlYgXP+oKYAl o4agxf+CmcbnumrITYjNGz2j8SW7J1l0/FmMSc9wZFkkeyaFDZVUiO5vr4ySJE84iyjoLAmWGVV8 aeODPaDhJSGyqnJfAr1o24NllUJHQ+GUp+sUhiFXW8MULfaZaU1sc3oB8OpC1uWLkHky2BaQhlIW Wzr3IZBpEXiRJ+QBTxuLpd5pXC6V79q6idoqwSaSJMPK7zFJxiKujbQWE6TS3mEELY6ovTum2S0c rDy0ByMLpkwtwB2s3cXRakmakMb3YvBh1eiTNxFD2a9j1ZvIkimSWwv2lB3CwJOaom7nrSA8ZoLE Ao4cI+HOauKGbuhcrVSghGBICYr1h8I0TaneGsuYfVodqnFYIld3qFxhSdWxB/aXAXb1nu4/g2VU d52CNZ1WkiCDqVUs66pBq3cqOyXVDXcqVIH1jOxOJc6Cmi5s9+jeo7sW3Y1XL3vg7IGzIy0yjeIy LTKuU1UvFYjbkWVa1OgOtKgD+aXESBkp3DVQFdOYGr/2/x3s277t277t29dt/wDzwxckACgAAA== ------=OPENWEBMAIL_ATT_0.810408543420152 Content-Type: application/x-gzip; name="queries_timing_postgresql.txt.tar.gz" Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="queries_timing_postgresql.txt.tar.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 H4sICMlMTkQAA2swTG9jYi50YXIA1F3dchu5cva1nyCXKOf4rFTHokmJ+tstp0qW5bM6kSWvJO9m T6VqCpwByVkNB6PBjGRu6SLvkJfLG+Qql7lPdwOY/yFnaG0qYZ2zoijO9zUajUaj0YDvUxH7QjmJ v/DDmRNJlcxioe6DQfI1efE8r+FoODwYj1/8G7z/hz//+38Md/cOD/fGL4b4Gu3vDQ8PXoyG4929 8e7ueB8+Hx0Od4cv2PCZ+Fe+UpXwmLEXfCoCPxKt31NpqNr/+v/2NfG8cPruH5may0fGg+CHl6z0 CvlClD9hT5XfmRJJAsZT/bj2vdaXJ5Qb+1Hiy/DlzrrXX9Z+o9/3Nny9ZNzznIWvFI6baSwX9fbL 6bRD65/YSZrIBU98FzpgibiKGWCW8EkgWCymIhahKxRLJPt4ffWJuQFPlVADkCN25/6DcFy5WPDQ a8BH0006yPHLyYVBQ2qDhwwwSGIe+DxEPyF+lyEIslFLz8NExFEsEsVOTm9u3zD6zxn+B0W/Obll HP6U8THkY0RIciRzEaKe0FRIFpkmRfyDYQcx4Hs3KAGAsQX/6i/ShebxQ7BlV4YeqRnaHwUiEaBq H1gr7Foc+cDdNK11fV+13IAPMgIVQFU6iWIJna5KZA4PebD8XTgK7EU4U+4mMgaQ4WC3E9llupiI GGRjSQoNhFYrAexvWBp5PIGeBTRPYMsVi2IffgNlGE7sHc6mMXCCDhAjFgHBtMiYzGE2mcvA09z7 wy4d9MQ++SF1S/gNspYFCnlEfVwh6mowt/gsYKtAiIhNRPIoRFjsrBgG2ZuCBZXZzQ8XplcH5OVL jboz6sb+s+bAx5l+HIgWfhD4hu0Nm0Lbc8J29gAm+mRzdr6QKY6FB+4H5JomApgFzBNRBE6jkxwl uyXDHXeSo2q4q2zA9EpXczU/StYKjBC4dLCPdnNdLyGIMZk9xj64RQe8vwP+KOKzknuFUdOln+B7 77l7N4uhgzymITP3lgsGJEwzgAzTIFVzFsFf6KmKLPC5i46vxDEc7O3tbSSLgQNuK8ckncK8tkaS bLhUGXY7+pK6JHoQkzuwI5n+rqrDqiBGEKd/fOdcXH/p0jkoS2PndBrQHToH5VjZOYF07xzl/16N DTOGo9Fxh9kIZj6IOxUjJDQK5vnqTsMDiwx/k2nsNMSg5umugU023b/XkGwSS+65HBwazCcPviso 0IXB6M4FtGyahuQxnIn0/Ep/gx/p8Hpip4jELBIzSF4aY2x1en12cnvGPn65PL09v7q0xJH0w8RR YraAvlAVwPWjrtJYa1+g04RD8IjWHcgZy/CL0xjFnxQB5pKosly1eMvI1XEcro25eorzyOOwtuxA cbqp6ULOYLxP2RTHO8CA+eXguY7mMLGJEAJynOWmsbhP4WOI0pM5RqdzX7GtvAnbKCFFiw5E69Dj 9VURKuKnC+fk5vT8vKvCNOR3CgTkOJehCwO7txQ5KazhnQXEixUnhWChTNDM16ol7yWNwwLxIAL8 iMO0DzpQ6HXAKeSCIT+sFfykzVfTvLGOuspfiHPcWFZtBNYHoTLTuianBQR5KtQ6Wg4Iie4kF0/5 E+xq1UDb1Yvn6jFTPojlpnGMSpFRWTBlgyPwnPBzYRdVVlEkWDj1YfnoB81d88TePvD4beBP3kYz dR+8hXiCvy1kaRCgLBg6NBGDsSy4HxqCNKY1C9q60Ky4wMJBJL66oDK/7NS6L1zOQgwCNXEU8DAU FNvAyrRAQnOIxPAb3fy9zjihGFHq+KEnvjoULVF8WoYfDobD9XNaofFGBmi9UMAHwReOa7OK0voH DoxRBXfnjNhNrLYVy8dt65/1HyBQDY2c0LegQxnXhMzk3F1rQr3lhI9ITEuOo+GXH8+uz4xQzWor CNUhHlgrFI1zI01BQBKsoDkUCZbtEmPp2EercNyAK1VwRBvM1xCJEfFdKB9DQ8AsATMEQI3DwvH8 WOCaojFabBhHq6mzcURfzbCB7ANo5iZZtgxZSnPcXL1hnz782rmd4KcidHfoJrg2UFw5kE+jafKB B6lu6cSB0aWDIhXxmkvvP3bBuHawjRMOoxaxKRYiLsE9ivQaZ/4+C6RbaKOd7osBNnqGRw7OW2Jo AvGS8Zg0E6OZkSaMGCTRJJ05mEBKlvDDD2vRSPdMlEfze8RjpfWM5g/uW2S9oQqE6Cv1Vzcl/Bxr V4gDjYCIykyk2tgwOqtyolDPwSm+CjelSUC3U7ZzxgIXBYkIS1jf1k4+xahFI1Nes8Y/5WkAU3QC MxV4H1c5CY9nmbfobmqFAIIgWQ7JNGSBjtKrDcNoA1dl6QqQmESMBY5j/SGZGU0tApeaRTnyqMHx lQz0dI348LxnooZE1JO7dTmKkVEORVFcNqGE4rH4vRZBkNqRYbBkvXKZVYUgzA7BYE+kCqWoCKAK Ejz6ydyRvleN0rpLcKp1Thxa74jJrs4/QES2tERIuQRP57sOTAsxj8GhcPhaCepP8Cdw/d0bTRDk tDQ2ZfQDWGzShLWQXqpzTwIW19B0TNtDh4jaWhrs/aCLwTdO3zArpgvaTmF8gn7brq/NVHPHiBTF oDnAmfjJgkcY7tSV3nG52xAJgiQYCAKvxt8hAvyjyqnnXM35rL5Mei5qxIdxAxSxmPHMAVYk+A0W fX+kBIwIKsTkCRqU/lzEhN+o9IUAP9jU5mdiJvzGNocQWgZSRg2Iz8KM+MLbIYomfiXumzT+bPxK Jwh8HjQqXsm4eVJ5JnrxNQp8F+IpIgJVRAXyBJzqH9n22/MPrNxo+C2CRie4pmrI13R36b/As8aX Tbh7pwIcUxqekrYy9vwQXDjTXLBugHCDByQEqARWoa1BY/fGf1Gm5T7FjuBVQJ4oTYpR+9m/fL44 Ob9kP59dv7+6OSN+ECXkgRP5XtNCv8f2LKZqje5hQbbgCmOqz6B1G0VGwvWnPghmFvrAHXNnCvNP AqujmV/JKW6SlsmT1QbQBMtICu0nLuiBHZ1Gy5YtuEEOK9UggGlG5JtQBYajvpLgNvgOLRBpepuI pcR89tyHAEelE5NnoJxVKBNmyXFDe6qWobuSpatNfJQx7soj3jyWof87tztNdu8nz0JNU9xU4TPh POqe3JjVWAIC5vsFmPJ6nAvM8sSgFIg1tC3o0JsXspsgy0zcy9UcfV3CTIQCc7ao96VN99itcqRz IOZpd39dE3B/Pfvp6ntmoHzyPZ5eTSSlqBONUcIHMT2BSxFY1IIilJUG5dVpsYaO6DostDT5mCC3 ozFNuMWDmYTemi8sbyRl0LJ18g28oec/+F4KLg/doXYRURqU9K9EIMy2hs+r+eEutQM5s4F6AJpY QLQJYwxj7Fbq8sZqBXLUibu4xMnQoOlUDQN6X6iyC6BuNwYCYswnvD3NylozrTMHHrRZ1ooYWYbo FXznVUOq9SXzcaJYwdvKSg/mvI2s9J0WXpieZrh5Ci4I8y6bL6Y+ZAjoSA0uw1wRahVDrP9Ft/63 K5hadWI5dZPct0/B2hIYzyjSXTyBNZUSfqgoU7Z500kk8KjkRf5ZxDDWpCpkyLBoLgUjnFCOg2NA AMMKuXewTiVUPo4QI5LuNmcOE3dtP3ODbEOGY9xMJp7mKZPeiWXdBGHuOr84+/6tSNy3aqm0FRkr hGf3B/AULJ9L2VjpZtNbAymDJ2zkQezxQ9vWLaDaTYzOTW5tru8iY+BqQ0xah1qUOO+vuyiZ9qR1 3jsw+RMIMClXhaUrhixZRiu8yQZk2eYe5bVh8jbaxqwRWhVaPqiZdmuKkjTu+G0gSdbNPJyluPUH 7lyPu4wBB1wW8Bl2CfM+b0q6b8hOLdPBJMXVlC/MWHQBktLcMAFCkNcSyT0bt55mDWW9iOyPoGxJ /qNbFKHDPQ9n3aYIcjQc7A7h/4eD8fBN/sveYRs/OhIztGJ2/pkZ7C2htjGs0ozwDtnlDIYYrPnc xqiph2elvXfKRKrUxR0liGRZDm24PNyGCm0qtIqhEhiR6zJz5XxkDofqzvPPZh1nadu3kbCDZw4+ sRltDo0CIA66S5URq1b19tVt6Ol6GoXbdTLEykQ3SKkgwTOhgmW1kUMjWi9Waq6Fs7lmW0brYd0D pYDFQhcNIDt0oYwd6IeJhOlyWUG1wfw69kzZORDQA/4MaK3zsoy0EQKkKMrGWjYrMAtmt/ipzKa4 4dCwvYNCYLe3lzXl+/s7r3/deb3Yee05r398/en1zaBge4Vm0+xOeBEGQnHYaF+NsUfvlmc9nXsO E/bnxot0ljXwQ4HJl6n/tQGta+BzKsMklrS60W6SErmEqtd/ZGvYYuTTzFgNY83RyQzPInatfq1V fOQ7aY07mnwiYVlk0hCWFLcgsOBRGKMc5BLqEVARj5gjHrbNbWXd0EkAqqgsENr1Le7VIwXjCbp4 LR4VLuk9IdBdk1htQcUzVhKVOGmvsHFQbjAsNVjfQWkSmo0y9BfBVMP0lCGWibZXVFgNezQed9oD zQ6UZD6AWWBtiNJ109hkhi7RslOQuSJBQ46ie4KipwR3fiAny0yG+mgoYocQC3aRIc8XYKSOyfl8 dJRsL/u8oet7d7ybLij58SD69j0sakMI+YWDe69WWbkYHfNxtwYF/BTyYTLczgOkA3TY5LVNqRP+ 1bKBIFg1BhEfyuw8yvgOHMGiTLA/2u2wM9lQ7wlIGPpoh0N5O5ylCoSm0MlsCMNja8LN0aanffLE WaF8r8Bl2ElpWGntmMKnCnvPgoQ6u4Lfg4SHQqYqWOoCQt1TWYmasZL8IBAJphZOtRI9Jzwc9tw5 rgtGm8SaASXRs9kUCzl0ZQPMHgksVu9oCFmJYhE05lOfRVUNFRQdJbO13DyuVX6SZOsFKy3T66Jl Nd7AkJJ7MdSUoMMkfOxAuDcrFRc8sYNOBd1N1Dku07iGjmop78SywSye2F7XLOuKluqySGQwLcSy LD1CimUnWQu7nOtZ3e1EQEcPyvUqSA7hH0z0wnNKNbcWtH9F77rhafmqlSsoC7h39w5WrFG5gsRw 7A7HHfKgDbIQLCNYOlyWzZNAG3GlwEN7WGoeL6PaGq7PFg4BZIiE3rZVkz21P+5iUoVG3Z5+1rDF 2Y/yCzAzYaeCgh08Zdl+5qdr+BHK4qHi/LgacWA5jqn58Rsy412XJBcgOuaAySRyOJjeDAdmy2We kAWj8aT22401u0+s03ApanR9xS7HaCkvSgArnorExYqYzMWjaEJnJpyWpEp3U6KTrJh3yM6uUhUc jxLcIzLwZtuc1FNcpMZiBg5sGvAH2ZjYeWLce8BAobUOrqYhgIRoLMYqgFinQtgrTfAKCJXA4861 uq8C0J8w3f8mSifBqqVYcXsGlLvgBtmkjXGi0jsG2doHdy30V3fuUx7QTi0JRAn75zw8Ygbali3x 3W4/RWLYbY65AfVoMBp0Of2XTyKG3mAiCQ0Yxx4va3i4t7cseGw9Gk2kaTko1pwsC/KgHJiCSZyF 9Np2KLoG/tfgMYpt1cgBloqr+wCm5bmApQEFuA0kXY+T6UU+jCsTCekwWqf1dPNstgzmCSyRh0nL nuHHwaVUsIaib+H4zc1FJWjGc2YehykJd5P0iRdT/aN6cnw3GAy+Y/ZZ2l7LK3+A2xT4aCVny7fm OvUNqlzs/AsM8hGdpc1qblXSPdvkZMNlKbFJq0hHH5LUSZYqUedSVhngRrvSRyJ3NFhhKYk5ZVu6 jwHJg58sMwFM55se+EYBCqS6DsukwfKLIlRGDJ5WJLiKNQ5F0aTQj/jvIpa4mtb80AXlVpuhBkyI nTPLx0aNb9RkAOupcRLGMTKX5rCeM2jZn2TsOwYaLbF0O4RKIUSmcyGoe3jKKy+du9d3NDjVQl5X BRIVYzj0NoqlJjmWitLb3PWDajpf419cnZ5c9MkeaEiYtQ3mq2ICgeqdzDd0laOXS0HLpGb03pvP oOpZzBc6c2Jrjsw6bMk+azjc4Mjypr4VDARK3AjWZbB6CPwHgQMzrdYgHq/TiPnep9oiBaPqDBu6 hhYnC58WoRVe3wuqhQeHnU7RoyLK5y99pVIc+yX2Jkq88OWBBwWow04rszrlyoaKRdQeUjxXCgJI JB4UqAUWJlOjTIiDl4X8fUWS8om9v775uVMclaUw7T04+nCB3oLHDtAJEXOrDp2swW+Cy1hQ6S/m QoSDKftpy8Hcrm7xr3o/Ac+w41mhGZ2Zzupf2cX5ze3ZJYlzeXV7/vHXjLy15rlPyIGFRcWtHz0H wQiWaeziiDT1Ckimg9m2IzU5aO+jNTZTWICGpVflkE2FuniIpn+711BXj9ZYbtSTE2K5qbinmsBN uG8x6FLsFS6d3l1+ubh4heVN9Cs7v2H0CRCmof8V+ti9E0nj1vkmR6kyGPDvsaDPvgDNDqyfOXUy smVbavqMlVeRBe+3qB4z2EAW+UhF6xrNLK7rslS4YUakC7yKuVBMnHfZcixwc6qNYEW0VRI0XjJU Qu4aB6+9b6jCVi/80+u4brnVHvcLVXgplwLWUow0kLd/K+naIkqHoPUlvvbr2R09NdK5X5nAu169 0kI6pctYzEa6nl6yQ1o1crSGMvm3tZhKKFcI8MiDVZMr26DKs7zVsENiWAq06dI6HkX95eTCSIK1 9s5CJHPZdNfdFKPzNeX9WhId5OsNagLLtqTg/669RCK7wilNCqX8TTtjZfxn3iXTVfVIS9scOAB/ hxWS4/EFqM5r2g3qs+KBMDZM6Xaq7IB/hLfjGHhtJnOYbSjM3xod7GJmDRYlsVTbL1+aWySzn/YN +1fPf7legvyFOVUOLgfv6eL/+d+4H3ymoO0Lztquk7yU7QV58MytH0l6wz7IUOrP9OuWT4Akv3By kwsj/1J7047zktk04hPjsziNOKYLJBWAOBHWzq7upf8KPay7KCxe6jgljvg+9R+k3bvk3lqWFo4a TpHF5R5HM1jfgtUsFqeI7Qk3wFQl74zejJ3jFNEhmoc/8+6Ct6AbnBJ0py7tAF3p0umd72QK9z2n oKBpM1t3ZVexrXpagHtjF2QFdGtUbeh9OrKOvk72vujUnyh1Ybj11UtTX2a4a7SxKe56+9gMl35q ZXgy7md7q3ATcNb6l1Wa6I6Lx4Jw8csRPJxupN8MYyU4OEcvXWUVPcEJd+rjVZkInw3MZvxm8AJG Fd76cm3K1vzaLLEZvhGjgYj0UlCRnPquD81qaEorET5YhSZjsaB2xLcO/mboJoyuPPR5qmS57zfn KUKtt6hmngLGGvhm6TeD972vjhtGv9mWtQ+x1fANiiFoiRcWuOhqfO6EPDOhHtBtUksndFuj+G+F ztQd7u2vSfBuDj0er8mnbg69tkKpF7Q9CIFbk5vqusWlEfwc/rAgz7YefVOXZoj8EOxPduL6NqJY uCLC6TsQsxZ7X03UHNNU0Slp+LzoCTgDH1rYoas36Wy8pUrfie+vdzd9hffDlR6mE3rLIAiz3t4c evWCjFhSh6rEkOsPZQn8cN7B3beztHcCoCu8wcEJuyUxeloQwT8AgcdbCkDWw1dDTsR94E4CrJ0s p1dUSOAiVugM+LLhNr6O4C0az4LZrsvWHqKTlWShZReCZvASTpGgGC13k7+XvUR3CV4r1EUrK+EJ pQTcGIavasGG04md078119Hg1eAjGAYzWmQCPd6ytYamFbqKU6TJl4bfZqAZTg28GuKv5NkszK8F 3Rum/ao4RY5e8Cs4ivBb+wer8r0M7xBORPzDy9OLLze3Z9fZH+w/w6D/RY4fXv58cvrly6d6nthc 0pT9MyP6fhFGhRJb5x+c89uzT9t0iRD7cHZ6cXJ9cnpyRW8Z8+mcFV32dXry4eTm9voK32DBzRb8 HMDj+TPv8G35o21SQgHl8ur2xPl4fnN6csEuPxLO5Ud8xsK/M7D29+3i0yiqgxDs3Dx8rp++/PjO vtk2G5tWmJPrn76c/3z1blT955ee9/XTl7PrX9nni5PL9f/M0v/910t2Yi71A8+8hXta70YHe8Px 4eD4eDCgt0eD4RDLuNS7EXv0vWT+brzNtribpDBBY6HEu+PR8Giwe3Q0GJh3x/b7eIUc/NzGHtn5 J8Z+xCvH/kZ35mmyg+HxeHcA/wOu4e7e7uDgwDw72j0Y7Y1bGPfG4/FgfLw/GByN4aG98Z59an80 hF+KvPpFzKcy9L5nW69g4hfxqwHls9g79oosz/xeeAYlvhH37AbvY8ObQO28jFUUtgV4bfVgcDAe 43UB+1qM3b2D4Qh+0cIfVYSHJ0Cpg929vf3BeG9UfqQueaY3Q7h/PDoaDY6ge+w7jXA4HO+OdtsV tjfY3zscDOw789Do+HB80MCac3+iewiLnTY6gL4+POglwNEB9DI8snsEejo6Pu5Er19agHrf2Xxe uQftpy1g2KJzOoHzP+1dW2/duBHus3/FeUiBeGEQvF+C5sFw4uK0iR3E3r4a2VyKAImzbRKg++87 Q5GSSIqSzi3OWYhYrJRjShwOyZlvLqT8qH73YbpJZyEMfu/vq3z0YQ5KSkwYSiaNslbUR98JWClU Ea5tjw1mgg1+Nvo0oGwUmKGGcBleJVxtmcIQCM5g1GAcnI4TgOM6m2i6Kb7xf77/4wmGJ/qsHnto cNUzo4iGucg4E8SKScqZJZLhKnNESR6qSz3FsX6prP8OyKezqPt9xrtzOdFOTLhJJ4oRDEY+TBMl 4bY6SXCkuAKJavvV53c4FxtMS09Cc23eKTXwsMpyIXFy+Wuv+nwKOjoGF9xILAvzg7uBwduUjTP7 AJU1ajFOXJw1W3WhKU0nwhTqKIZ5g2+69fbqfwFqQctPVo4xEHiWrT5/PXnMzBDwW00Bt18WrLZb +TNBtZNx7MQ4iNSoA1LsBHI1x2uoBqyFhQTy1wjAXLoOnzYDTnuCTEzxXHkBlaA2FaWSCGvroGkr uKSsKXgEYkN4TBvuJhDL9lCpbNwoGBTLUVVbVBjz0NKecNIPR0jM5upPgZ7XDJUPmBPS6FkoaWN8 JFy+MLSThHkFA+sJALrbACNtiI62wkUlxdwBqIOniOYgCpjeEBsdBhXtjoe4U4UBA6ICnhDcEaHM pphoQzQEUjBnNMxHC/OIhJut4MQPxEJlD8DmBMYhqNQge3eBdBshIc4pcEwr2UChQR9YgYCahNEE mPh9tv86v7uF316gL+vq5hngjaerxwEuff3++XGLRUisGRxeHUhpgEhX0eMTeE2vrYhZQl1/BszX tp0MCw2AtLMUl0Xo0wM+mJ77mNFTv9WjwGxATVO791O/Zvv2gur2L6vm1Yfjzd9Wrlf2DOOODLid JNKurwazlSqEElSAdgnwRSpnaasFc8jDQflpBWpQC84FMTK61QxPluzlx08guGEpPsbtjJ/e3J+u zq+e9f+ZDtaTJ+HIz1P/+M33315BrZNWQhUeQUEAdBH4v0r9gCynGL+WBhIGL9FqjZQanoiXqiQc zDZLgGTCUyAqqEk+QhR1DVF0nKhh6eaR7iN62jGo0NsSLXUCYNalDBowSAEFEX9parbaq0FECTn7 Uc770Dk5zyPOqHr7sKJseN5Vrfd0mPE9tUKLLvWVecN+/H/K/gGvCqPDM6FK1CD70nztUYQziyqq PFURVUxTNcywHtB/xE73taB5wzH+Uy3oCsM2XNAZVAE5axjYxGrEazPltEHfxy+5XkXHyBx/y9Xl 03XnMhnx87SOntZDkzpskocTbOJby9HF0wKCnA6hlqdir3r+iLT8yerKfxNp9cJ/dinR6tJSooK6 085UPRiUoE8Qpq2Ilh3YpLnnYqQZ14pdKXRV7jLAF9AGa9vgFV9FtSVhOzud1uU7b5Zga6WO2uX7 VkA08rtOX5BbnMWa41ZOXfmU8rfao7FtJaNaAv38qdSbryX0nB7V8EPwVQxih4M4ggDSRk3i5HRf A6CKzhdT9LXWy54uvP9Q+Lt20FaFH3NAYw2s/bZHOh093tdYtc54jfWx6Yd3tGaKCwQQrAivtEb3 FP7cdnZTAy3j0NLVJQ+PlTb2xlGQXL9V9DE2GjQyHw+BVM3609Xp4cIaR6Q0R0qIZqyvEjNKacYY SG70vyqJWCwGyIVwrPWClpYy/JUSI1BNKmOUJEKyqst8t4BG1boXVgnWhjMQursunFFQHHJAmNRU E6N6T6FffDSeobhGkQNKI9wNsKhI/7CWEWQMiXczohmFmcu5QY2/UcuMcnR8oONWOSIon2i4KZUx 2iKSURu7+w98/vgNKSiBk01ZoqSpD15OTX8gOVcwwTHK39xMZ0EgKwWokXAz29c/GmuY27qkRGI0 3Uli9bHFGZhiru2k4EzXjXEJY0qAy4LFqXCoIEOxSB1xFjO0/PXBAgxbpVqAzQCTkmCURtKtSG/K eGhhz85KMJISWyliskY4PZx7gynvRGXGxKpVuoa5VvVwwOMKlrt0vEGLbhAtzssofudPxvcwLaC0 U//pti/33978+/3nM4RG5y/vXj+/fP76+dXF+rz5sNvn378MwblD4bnN81mev3z1+vnNOV79o3DF uuHn0HL4V/JgAIF3r15fXzy/uTl/do0/+XfAte9HSUDjaTgX6bc/So41R98O/OVQAPP44eXJ6u/I zkIucM0tVwSlOzcCI6E8GJe8pgysMpizgAk2TGhKbBuqtgVE62ce9JvSWghNWqtPUslcLTXUt6dR jjrhNNh0egpZdEkH796TN597+/mmElMk5gAZhKBghwMU5WYOhcxqQB+YboCykwk6D/r8zJkpVoPF 0CYhcAfqvor7mAKWecQmMD1kBLXnZPenR8t6iZNKzUgHZTAvBAaxAPlJMHTasbKCUjahZPeRmGK0 IpiQKrgUYD1MUwzzxMdawMDpwMx8JHVEeNExxIswPorvihcNpkhpQppr8zYHE64qLgDkAFJorr3q WyQJ9wfbMcLmU+G/jwgiC6x1/JbBNlSMjnk8DiEZ8PDjRknIpQUEw4yLEGSuKbo5BMsk8+CcOrFD N0c728HdXmfDjxu2kE/2EYwP2opYVrJADzgt0OyVREeptQMLCmuJeE1L2kjjSHDZNM5901XdjoZh VpW7tld+D3giIWbRKRqnr2Jb05lzyVLvM/CXIJ6MrnsMwoj5a6/69iPW51NcmnDNdOos6jA6g84k gDxqkLbMeGGgTECtiCapng97ujdxde/J072Jq7upWs3a6jm/p9PMdjaZxhLTwJjbJoMsvPPhc8iO ypAZDC8bSXADDiAuAFMurBBl5IhPmWP2lSWmjd9mmWJRmBTGUWjLoGSP0bl6iFk1bhMT3Say4kCu hpixOTbZTggx406Gejtdaw+R5MRYE2Qukpw2jjJnKU6jnTpwmFkOBirZUGpN0acinoxQZgjAj4dh NzHoUrXMAA23+4+5HQvAcD+NReu/7zLUaiHZXrO5+Voatb2XDGRo1lIye7Z939XZzYjdkrlUmpQ3 mjf1g1O67AY5msOrqZ+puees1pDMqMaJ+8EcM0mOxJ6S4MCOY7CARtzDE97hHGecrV69vvZgBK+/ 3l7fXV+uL9bnL87Qc3xxfXdx9eofdxevLuGZm9v11fnt+es1POURB9TosMabr6t4MtBZPNaicew2 R1vA3//z7d0av4V3VnNSx1pX8JavPzCv4FD7KnsPBPb6q6+f8T3mFoZ/pn7nPQxZ563e0wsPe5AH lqNCibNLzQUulBBUe7+0cII6TmS7Y1RoI1ooJoqtQ0w4gmdu4L487gCOBvmkhOS6POej7+7stwpP S0viZuxZreKGCTzqg1ni2oBY9bCMxCGeAI4zf+4SKc9QPcMEsbdfmsM33/7+ITljcSIjgnGuAEYI jsd5WIfhAjqrb5xqZQBzo0dJaCGJ0CN7Wvul4jkKnUo9R+HHeipC3hfc7Y994cyhl4fN7Ys0hOHO Bu58ekm0DKb6Mtqj0aNZ8t7sYc8xz/G9BjvFOwiBFSZq2XldKnxbzKG6Fj6UFG67eIukUc3zAd4K S6z30sXbeVGHnJwyBAR2Je4y3ZQkAxzUAh9zFIxGbeTmBDVlrwe75P09RKDI2tZVjIEia1yNSdKB MS7RV4rBHiq25lEhTeOgCUc5UTNCMUA2kRizYxj65+2inhU8KstWp8DkPSqEj8At2ujtMGi/zQiJ CRCdCrfna4UH6Wycq1OWQ54Qk/d/z1EoToEFmMsFzOMxZrMLL4pcNR8hqEYKytOmYKIZh/lA/mbn WMEw5zYPaZR5kcShGSVAnrGk/twsPtCSfpeXjnNWV4O4lAgfEvXXrvaMU596fY56Hq/5TrNpGgBO iYYE1kZxExIyY1Bp4/DAqlGX+4THvbWi0N2+vmqNnbuX5+ubu/PbX8E6wo0IX983X6KMf08MpVXr iP785n9oh/HUbvKGXN9e49UdUBcvwh6o/Fycp/G1pY88/iUmAfVpjPlC3l3u35rm8GS0Qw2e1hg8 k5F3J+ZAy1d3l9dreOR2DWYTtP2U+tZC6T6blcYPRBlA6LNIrLreifLUoIwVcQO6mOIDxg5aVgxR fvoNh5mt3n+CIaer9/fvDmToHbt1dzKsJ5JV7yTIWK2davfV9BUFLw8Mgdp4pA0eMmLxP3hO1hTG tBONOwHGCwZuw12bSlnJE+VE+2Mb/TVzXGH7iRhc33/8lvtAq4TgUSgGlWBzZycJUY56QlR0itcJ 6Tdd1UBvs4xyIMSCUA7clVbVdtMhDco1tERlSSdpaUrnWv54f/fhy8c7/IIpGLYwWUDy0HAUQHQ7 j7xowN081PtdAxKiiEjw8YHqOTpNzhrKFWDYMfbEkrs/E1T3aM4bWkYnOSmPWOEArm+sBBNLzlge LCwPNm8mzBqV5Hsu2ZBk05YhEg9zduR4wiYDQ4RlpmZN13wUqnwc6Vn+PbOp83EUoWyc6cw2OY3N NWW6oYbWNlhm/cGmN4h9jc6xx0kuJ/JHhJU8vMoHkiW4FRwWjpHh4B07nC7hy4LgHgrBlWcLHQ1o Wy2obbDMQW1gpBvDrMHzG4N0kkYxU4VtDOQt96aboCBiJbG2ei7sNGpTlkuNeaMk3OkJtST9sWfE X/ODQHZBbdA8dUQ6TwjcqYmTxoEAhpvQmutBUJuyzIGiNpOoDUCvz+9DWmIOwTw1uKC2I0Ntanp5 oLMXr3FnLX8A1GYmUVs4/ijiuyNHbRIFR3P9SVEb3xS1CaqdxQ16eJzD6s23FaP0r6u3v3+fQHAL hFsg3ALh9lVmOd4ArzmmAAW0Hx/RRvEqgnMYkPDBVsWsNSDfxE4ADt4lrMdNeDdx8KDBIzGMT7zt 8h33A+CY0YR6JOnvJpCkQQQpPSFd0G7vAE6LFqCMATjcpcAaWmJKwALgegBOJ4nAxwzgJrAELgtG w/KgDwfg5GwAR/8EAE5jtB9PmOhCxMcP4JgSTFs82HwugPvLUpaylKUsZSlLWcpSlrKUpSxlKUtZ ylKWspSlLGUpS/kJy/8BOY/h6gDwAAA= ------=OPENWEBMAIL_ATT_0.810408543420152--